The Most Rev. Dr O’Dwyer, Bishop of Limerick, expressed concerns yesterday during a prize distribution at one of Limerick’s schools about the unusual choice of one of Thackeray’s novels for next year’s Intermediate program. Despite acknowledging the novel’s status as a masterpiece, his Lordship argued that the book may not be appropriate for the intended educational purpose. Dr O’Dwyer cited Colonel Newcope, who stressed the importance of respecting the innocence of youth. Both the Bishop and many others are left puzzled by the selection and its suitability for young students.

The Bishop’s concerns highlight the ongoing debate surrounding the appropriateness of certain literary works in educational settings, especially for young and impressionable students. This incident raises questions about the process through which books are selected for academic programs and the criteria used to determine their suitability. It is crucial to strike a balance between exposing students to classic literature, promoting critical thinking skills, and ensuring that the content aligns with their age and maturity levels, in order to create a well-rounded educational experience.

Northants Evening Telegraph – Tuesday 01 July 1902