In a speech delivered at the Protestant Synod for the Diocese of Limerick, Dr Bunbury, Bishop of Limerick, expressed the Protestant viewpoint on university education. Dr Bunbury stated that the Protestant community is satisfied with the educational opportunities provided by Trinity College and suggested that slight changes to its constitution could potentially encourage Reformed faith adherents outside of the Protestant church to avail themselves more of the educational benefits it offers. However, he acknowledged the Church of Rome’s resistance to Trinity College as a centre of mixed education, as they insist on a state-funded university where members of their church can be educated without any perceived threat to their faith or morals.
Dr Bunbury empathized with the limited perspective of Catholic bishops and priests who prefer to keep young men from their church away from Trinity College. While acknowledging that the atmosphere within Trinity College is not explicitly Roman Catholic in its religious or civil aspect, he dismissed the notion that it is permeated with racial distinction or religious dominance. Dr Bunbury attested that the faith of Roman Catholic students has never been compromised within Trinity College, and he challenged the notion that their “Catholicity” is blunted by their association with Protestant students. On the contrary, he argued that such interactions foster tolerance and a liberal mindset without weakening the students’ religious beliefs.
Dr Bunbury pointed out that as long as Catholic bishops maintain their opposition to joint secular education in Ireland’s national university, it is unlikely that any concessions Trinity College authorities can make will satisfy them. He questioned whether anyone concerned about the welfare and peace of the country could allow the higher education of priests and people in Ireland to remain in its current state, emphasizing the lamentable lack of higher education within the Catholic Church. He highlighted evidence presented before the University Commission by a Roman Catholic clergyman, indicating a deficiency in the education of clergy and laity alike. Dr Bunbury believed that improved education among the ruling majority, who exert political and civil influence throughout most of Ireland, would lead to a more liberal and tolerant society.
Dr Bunbury acknowledged that the majority of the members of the Church of Ireland who understand the issue are not rigidly opposed to a settlement that would provide Roman Catholics with favourable university education conditions. He cited proposals put forward by Mr Balfour in 1899, as well as the idea of establishing a fully equipped Roman Catholic college in conjunction with the Royal University while leaving Trinity College unaffected. However, he emphasized the Church of Ireland’s strong opposition to any interference with Trinity College, asserting that the venerable institution has been remarkably successful for centuries. Dr Bunbury praised Trinity College’s ability to produce accomplished individuals of various creeds and cautioned against any scheme that would undermine its prosperity.
In conclusion, Dr Bunbury expressed gratitude for the recent appointment of Dr Trail as the Provost of Trinity College, interpreting it as a sign that the Prime Minister does not intend to legislatively harm the university. He affirmed Trinity College’s ability to maintain its prestige and attract bright minds without fear of competition. Dr Bunbury expressed the Church of Ireland’s unwavering support for Trinity College and its commitment to preserving its position as a beacon of education in Ireland.
Limerick Echo – Tuesday 21 June 1904
