In a case that unfolded yesterday before the Lord Chief Justice and a specially convened city jury, the matter of Cloncurry v. Ryan was brought to light. The plaintiff, Frederick Baron Cloncurry, initiated legal proceedings against Martin Ryan, a resident of Owneybeg, County Limerick. The crux of the dispute revolved around the possession of lands situated in Rath, County Limerick, encompassing approximately 95 acres, 2 roods, and perches, alongside a dwelling and associated premises.

The origins of the legal contention stemmed from an agreement delineated in writing, dated 11th February 1891, wherein the plaintiff had purportedly leased the aforementioned lands to the defendant for grazing or pasture purposes. Central to this arrangement was the contention that the tenancy could be terminated by providing six months’ written notice, a stipulation that purportedly elapsed on May 1st, 1914. However, the defendant contested these assertions, refuting the nature of the land use and challenging the validity of any termination notice.

Presenting the case on behalf of the plaintiff were Mr Jellett, K.C., and Mr Maxwell, acting under the instruction of legal representatives from Messrs. White and White. Conversely, the defendant was represented by Mr P. D. Fleming, K.C., and P. Kelly, under the instruction of Mr P. O’Donnell.

Following due deliberation and under the direction of the Lord Chief Justice, the jury delivered their verdict, finding in favour of the plaintiff. The ruling implies a validation of Lord Cloncurry’s claims regarding the nature of the tenancy agreement and the applicability of the termination notice.

The implications of this verdict reverberate beyond the immediate parties involved, resonating within the legal and agricultural domains. Such cases underscore the significance of clear and unambiguous contractual arrangements, particularly concerning land tenure, thereby elucidating the importance of meticulous documentation and adherence to legal formalities in property transactions.

In conclusion, the resolution of Cloncurry v. Ryan underscores the pivotal role of the judiciary in adjudicating disputes arising from contractual intricacies, whilst also serving as a testament to the enduring relevance of legal principles in safeguarding property rights.

Dublin Daily Express – Wednesday 17 January 1917