Dear Sir,

I hope this letter finds you well. I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the recent publication of the Mungret College “Annual” and the apparent discrepancy between its portrayal of an Irish institution and the actual state of affairs within the college.

While it is heartening to witness the positive reception of the “Annual” by both the Gaelic League and its readers, it is disheartening to learn that Mungret College may not truly embody an Irish spirit in its everyday workings and inner life. As individuals who hold great hope for the youth of Ireland, it is essential that we ensure they are not only shielded from the perils of cultural dilution but are also prepared to actively contribute to their country’s real-life endeavours.

Ideally, Mungret College should serve as a beacon of Irish heritage, nurturing students who are deeply rooted in Irish lore, well-versed in ancestral traditions, and fervently committed to the noble cause of building an Irish Ireland. Regrettably, it appears that the college falls short in this regard.

The “Annual” itself seems to be a façade, promoting a falsely projected Irish identity while the essence of Mungret College remains as Irish as the generic town featured on recruiting posters plastered on the walls of Gairvowen. These posters, claiming the glories of Erin in the British fighting line, bear some resemblance to the Mungret College Annual, which allocates only a fraction of its content to the Irish language.

I implore you to address these concerns and ensure that Mungret College aligns itself authentically with the principles and values that define Irish culture. Let us not allow the rich heritage of Ireland to be overshadowed by mere tokenism or diluted by external influences.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. I trust that you will take the necessary steps to rectify the situation and uphold the true spirit of Mungret College.

Yours sincerely,
[Unnamed]

Dublin Leader – Saturday 16 January 1904