A recent meeting of the Limerick Asylum Committee saw a fervent discussion centered around the election of an assistant medical superintendent. Lord Emly, a prominent figure at the gathering, put forth a compelling argument urging support for a candidate affiliated with the Catholic University School of Medicine. This move, according to Lord Emly, would align with the counsel provided in a Pastoral letter from the Hierarchy issued in 1900.
In his impassioned address, Lord Emly emphasized that backing a candidate who had studied at the Catholic University School of Medicine would be consistent with the guidelines set forth by the Hierarchy. He contended that the school, which had been established by Bishops, held the distinction of being the first medical school in Ireland, despite its lack of the financial resources enjoyed by other secular institutions.
Lord Emly underscored the importance of Catholic public bodies supporting their own educational institutions, noting that the election of Dr Roberts, a product of the Catholic University School of Medicine, would be a meaningful step in this direction.
However, the meeting also witnessed dissenting voices. Dr Connery expressed his reservations about raising such a question, suggesting that Lord Emly’s stance could be misconstrued and used against them by their opponents.
Amidst the deliberations, there were supporters who found merit in Lord Emly’s proposal. These advocates agreed with his viewpoint, believing that adhering to the principles outlined in Lord Emly’s remarks was crucial.
Four candidates were presented for consideration: Dr Coffey, Dr M‘Daonnell, Dr Irwin, and Dr Roberts. The decision-making process culminated in a final poll between Dr Coffey and Dr Roberts, resulting in an even split of 8 votes each. As the Mayor lacked the authority to cast a tie-breaking vote, the election ultimately fell through.
Consequently, the committee resolved to address the impasse by scheduling a new meeting for the same purpose, to be held one month from the present date. A fresh advertisement has been ordered to inform interested parties about the forthcoming session.
The deliberations showcased the complex interplay between educational affiliations and professional appointments, with differing perspectives on whether allegiance to a specific institution should influence such decisions. The forthcoming meeting is anticipated to provide further insights into the outcome of this critical election process.
Free Press (Wexford) – Saturday 21 October 1905
