In the wake of the passing of Judge Adams, a plethora of tales, both authentic and apocryphal, have emerged, each a testament to the unique personality of the late jurist. Among the myriad narratives circulating, let’s unravel an authentic tale that captures the essence of Judge Adams’ wit and penchant for plain speaking.
The protagonist in this real-life courtroom drama is a man named Dwyer, who had the unfortunate experience of falling victim to the age-old three-card trick, a classic con game designed to separate the unwary from their money. Undoubtedly feeling aggrieved, Dwyer brought his case before the Limerick County Court, seeking justice and redress for the perceived swindle.
As Dwyer recounted his tale of woe, Judge Adams, renowned for his straightforward and often humorous approach, didn’t mince words. In a candid assessment, the judge remarked that individuals like Dwyer belonged to the “large and numerous class” commonly referred to as “mugs.” This colloquial term, implying someone easily deceived or taken advantage of, sets the tone for the unfolding proceedings.
Judge Adams continued his candid commentary, pointing out that Dwyer had demonstrated the three stages of a “mug”: first, losing his money; second, seeking its return; and third, escalating the matter by involving the police. The judge, with his characteristic wit, highlighted the folly of such actions and suggested that people did foolish things every day.
To drive home his point, Judge Adams presented a humorous analogy. He likened Dwyer’s predicament to that of a young lady who might allow herself to be kissed—a foolish act in itself. However, the judge humorously added that the young lady would be doubly foolish if she went on to tell her mother about the incident.
This anecdote showcases Judge Adams’ unique ability to blend legal acumen with relatable, down-to-earth humor. His courtroom, far from a sombre arena, became a stage for both justice and entertainment. The late judge’s approach to these cases not only addressed the legal matters at hand but also left an indelible mark on the memories of those who had the privilege of witnessing his courtroom theatrics.
As the stories about Judge Adams continue to circulate, this authentic tale serves as a delightful window into the wit and wisdom that defined the proceedings of the Limerick County Court under his watchful gaze.
Islington Gazette – Friday 10 April 1908
