In a novel case presented at the Limerick Quarter Sessions before Judge Adams, Laurence Keane from Castleconnell filed a lawsuit against Kate and Daniel Hickey, claiming £32 35 in alleged unpaid wages. Mr Doyle, the solicitor representing the plaintiff, brought forward an unusual aspect of the case. He stated that his client had been inconvenienced on multiple occasions by forged postcards, strongly suspecting that the handwriting belonged to Kate Hickey.

Kate Hickey vehemently denied the accusation, asserting that the plaintiff had been fully paid. Mr Doyle requested that she write the name “Lawrence Keane” to compare it with the suspected forged postcards. In a lighthearted moment, Judge Adams compared the situation to the infamous Piggott case. He instructed Kate Hickey to sit down, take a pen, and write the following: “James Doyle. Come into me on Friday next, as I want to see you,” and concluded with a humorous remark, “and the law yours, James Doyle.” The witness complied with the judge’s instructions.

After examining the two writings, Judge Adams determined that they bore no resemblance whatsoever. Consequently, he dismissed the action, highlighting the importance and limitations of handwriting analysis in the case at hand.

Limerick Echo – Tuesday 11 October 1904