Castlepook’s Reindeer Puzzle
Archived: 16 September 2026
Abstract
31,590 BCE is a modern filing date within late Marine Isotope Stage 3, not a recoverable Irish calendar year. Ireland contained varied cold environments, including tundra wetlands at Derryvree and changing regional ice cover. Castlepook Cave’s fauna, re-dated using improved methods, includes reindeer, mammoth, giant deer, hyaena and other cold-adapted animals, though its poorly recorded bones do not represent a single moment or community. A cut-marked reindeer femur may indicate Upper Palaeolithic carcass processing, but lacks associated tools, hearths or human remains. Evidence supports possible fleeting human visits, not settlement, polities or culture. Further excavation and secure dating remain essential.