An interesting case was heard by Judge Adams at the Quarter Sessions. The Limerick No. 1 Rural District Council brought an action against Stephen Heffernan and John Barry to recover £46 for making good the default in building a labourer’s cottage. Heffernan was the contractor, and Barry was a surety. Heffernan had disappeared, and a curious fact emerged regarding the sureties. The bond was signed by Barry and a “William Dwyer,” but it appeared that the latter signature was a forgery.

John Connolly testified that he had signed the name “William Dwyer” to the bond at Heffernan’s request, even though he knew it was a forgery. Connolly was asked by Heffernan in the presence of Barry, and he was not aware it was a crime. His Honor explained the definition of forgery to Connolly, who admitted his guilt.

John Barry, one of Heffernan’s sureties, acknowledged that he was aware Connolly’s signature was a forgery when he saw it. His Honor remarked on the laxity of the law and its enforcement throughout the country, and he criticized the whole situation. He suggested that the case be wrapped up rather than allowing it to continue. His Honor issued a decree for £30 against both Connolly and Barry, allowing for installment payments.

The case highlighted issues of lawlessness and forgery within the context of a contract dispute, leading Judge Adams to comment on the state of affairs in the country.

Limerick Echo – Tuesday 04 April 1905