At the Abbeyfeale Petty Sessions, several cases were heard involving Mr William Colbert, a Justice of the Peace, and Mr James McGrath, a publican from Athea. The court consisted of Magistrates Mr James Woulfe Flanagan, R.M B.L; W. L, C. Harnett, M. G. Barry, and T. Hurley.

Thomas Fitzgerald obtained decrees for possession against John Grady and Denis Sexton.

Mr James McGrath, a publican, summoned Mr William Colbert, J.P., of Templeglantine, accusing him of using abusive and threatening language towards him. In retaliation, Mr Colbert filed a cross-case against Mr McGrath for assault and abusive language.

The court proceeded to hear both cases together. Mr McGrath’s representative, Mr D. Leahy, presented the case against Mr Colbert, emphasizing that Mr McGrath was a respected publican who had retired with a pension from the Royal Irish Constabulary. He accused Mr Colbert of displaying animosity towards him and trying to expel him from his premises. Mr Colbert, acting as a Justice of the Peace, had confronted Mr McGrath and alleged he was selling drinks illegally.

The magistrates questioned the relevance of some details and the animosity between the parties. Mr McGrath explained the incident where he refused to serve Mr Colbert. The court ultimately dismissed both cases, stating that they hadn’t heard all the evidence.

A licensing case against Mr McGrath for an alleged sale of drink without a license was also heard. However, the case was dismissed as no sale was proved. The court acknowledged Mr McGrath’s excellent character and noted that they would convict if evidence of a sale was presented.

The proceedings showcased the tension between the parties and the complexity of the legal issues involved.

Kerry News – Monday 27 February 1905