Bread Failure538 CE

The surviving annal entries associated with 538 CE are sparse and uneven. Two annal traditions record a failure of bread, while others place different events under the same year-labels, including a battle at Claenloch and regnal notices. The surviving entries also show that the dating is not uniformly presented across the texts.

Lithographic historical reconstruction: Bread Failure

Annal Record

In the entries aligned with 538, the Annals of Ulster and the Annals of Tigernach both record a failure of bread. In the same Ulster year-group, a papal notice for Silverius follows, showing that the year contains more than one kind of entry. The Annals of the Four Masters do not repeat the bread failure here; instead, their 538 entry gives an Irish regnal frame and a different event, including the slaying of Tuathal Maelgarbh. Chronicon Scotorum likewise assigns a different event to A.D. 538, namely the battle of Claenloch, where Maine son of Cerbhall was slain. [1] [2] [3] [4]

Dating Issues

The surviving material also shows that 538 is not presented in a single, uniform way across these annals. The Annals of Ulster supply explicit AD headings in their chronology table, while the Annals of Tigernach excerpts show year markers without printed AD headings in the excerpted table. The Four Masters give an Age of Christ heading for 538, and Chronicon Scotorum does the same, but the events attached to that year differ from one text to another. [1] [2] [3] [4]

Source References

Hover over a number to see the source. Select it to open the source.

  1. [1] Annals of Ulster
  2. [2] Annals of Tigernach
  3. [3] Annals of the Four Masters
  4. [4] Chronicon Scotorum

Primary Sources

  1. Annals of Ulster
  2. Annals of Tigernach
  3. Annals of the Four Masters
  4. Chronicon Scotorum