Tola Feimhin571 CE

The notices linked with 571 CE are brief and uneven. In the Annals of Ulster, the entry numbered U572 carries the printed heading AD 571 and records the slaying of two descendants of Muiredach, naming their killer, along with deaths of bishops and abbots nearby in the sequence. The Annals of Tigernach and the Annals of the Four Masters both print the year 571 and record battles at Tola and Feimhin, but they differ in detail and emphasis. The notices can be compared as annal wording, not harmonized into a single reconstructed narrative.

Lithographic historical reconstruction: Tola Feimhin

Annal Notices

In the Annals of Ulster, the sequence around U571 and U572 places the deaths and slayings beside one another in a tightly dated framework. U571.0 is printed as AD 570, and U571.2 adds the alternative notice, “Or this year the repose of Mo-Laise of Daiminis.” U572.0 is printed as AD 571. In U572.1 the annalist records the slaying of two descendants of Muiredach, namely Baetán son of Muirchertach and Echaid son of Domnall son of Muirchertach Mac Erca, and states that they were killed by Crónán son of Tigernach. U572.2 then notes that Maenu, bishop of Cluain Ferta Brénainn, rested, while U572.3 gives the death of Demán son of Cairell. The Ulster entry therefore joins royal violence, ecclesiastical death notices, and an alternative memorial note within the same year grouping. [1]

Battle Accounts

The Annals of Tigernach give a fuller battle account for the same cluster of events. Under Annal T571, the text records the slaying of Muredach’s two grandsons, Baetán son of Muredach and Eochaid the Fair son of Domnall, in the third year of their reign, and names Cronan son of Tigernach, king of Connacht, as their slayer. The entry then adds that the battle of Luimnech was gained by the Cianachta, and that Cronan himself fell there. Tigernach’s phrasing keeps the killing and the battle together, making the sequence both genealogical and military. The Four Masters, by contrast, place the year under The Age of Christ, 571 and record two separate engagements: the battle of Tola, by Fiachna son of Baedan son of Cairell, against the people of Osraighe and Eile, and the battle of Feimhin, by Cairbre son of Creamhthann, king of Munster, against Colman Beg son of Diarmaid. In that version, both the defeated side and the place-names are explicit, and Tola is identified as a plain between Cluain Fearta Molua and Saighir. [2] [3]

Monastic Deaths

Monastic and episcopal deaths recur in several of the annalistic traditions, and the notices are not always synchronized. In the Ulster sequence near U572, Maenu, bishop of Cluain Ferta Brénainn, is said to have rested, and Demán son of Cairell is also recorded there. The same sequence had already noted at U571.2, “Or this year the repose of Mo-Laise of Daiminis.” In Tigernach, Maenu bishop of Cluain Fearta Bréanainn rested at T570.2, and later T572.2 says Bréanann of Birr rested. The Four Masters place Oenna Mac Ua Laighisi, abbot of Cluain Mic Nois, in M569.2, St. Ite in M569.3, St. Maeineann, bishop of Cluain Fearta Breanainn Clonfert, in M570.2, and St. Brenainn, abbot of Birra, in M571.1. This is a dense memorial landscape of abbots, bishops, and saints, expressed through short entries rather than narrative explanation. [1] [2] [3]

Royal Deaths

The royal deaths and successions are recorded in parallel but not identically. In the Annals of Ulster, U572.1 names Baetán son of Muirchertach and Echaid son of Domnall as the slain descendants of Muiredach, and says that Crónán son of Tigernach was their slayer, in the third year of their reign. Tigernach’s T571.1 gives the same pair, though with the names rendered as Muredach’s two grandsons Baetán son of Muredach and Eochaid the Fair son of Domnall, and again identifies Cronan son of Tigernach, king of Connacht, as the killer. In the same broader years Tigernach also records the death of Conall son of Comgall, king of Dálriada, in T573.1. The Four Masters place Conall son of Comhgall, king of Dal Riada, in M572.3, and the killing of Aedh son of Eochaidh Tirmcharna by the Ui Briuin in M574.2. These entries show how the annals track death, kingship, and kinship together, sometimes in closely matching forms and sometimes with different emphases. [1] [2] [3]

Textual Comparison

The year 571 is presented in different chronological forms across the compilations. In Ulster, U572.0 carries AD 571; in Tigernach, Annal T571 is the heading; and in the Four Masters the year appears as The Age of Christ, 571. Yet the entries are not simply equivalent. Ulster records the slaying of two descendants of Muiredach and nearby alternative notices, including the repose of Mo-Laise of Daiminis. Tigernach records the slaying of Muredach’s two grandsons and the battle of Luimnech. The Four Masters instead record the battle of Tola and the battle of Feimhin. Even when the dates align broadly, the contents differ in selection and detail, which suggests that each annalistic tradition preserved its own editorial habits and local interests. Names also vary in spelling: Muiredach or Muredach, Crónán or Cronan, and Cluain Ferta Brénainn or Cluain Fearta Breanainn. [1] [2] [3]

Period Context

The surrounding years help locate these notices in a broader annalistic rhythm. In the Ulster sequence, U570 records the killing of Fergus son of Néilléne and the deaths of Aenu, Íte, Gildas, and Aedán of the Uí Fhiachrach. U573.1 records the battle of Feimen, in which Colmán Bec son of Diarmait was defeated but escaped, while U574.1 records the battle of Tola and Fertola in the territories of the Cruithin, followed by U574.3’s alternative note identifying the plain between Éile and Osraige and between Cluain Ferta Mo-Lua and Saighir, with Fiachra son of Baetán as victor. The Four Masters similarly carry the sequence forward: M572.2 gives the battle of Doete, also called Bealach Feadha, by Aedh son of Ainmire against the men of Meath, where Colman Beg son of Diarmaid fell; M573.2 notes Breanainn son of Brian, chief of Teathbha, died; and M574.2 records the killing of Aedh son of Eochaidh Tirmcharna by the Ui Briuin. Taken together, the notices show a compact span in which battle, dynastic change, and monastic memory are continuously interleaved. [1] [3]

Source References

Hover over a number to see the source. Select it to open the source.

Support Emerald Archives on Buy Me a Coffee
  1. [1] Annals of Ulster
  2. [2] Annals of Tigernach
  3. [3] Annals of the Four Masters

Primary Sources

  1. Annals of Ulster
  2. Annals of Tigernach
  3. Annals of the Four Masters