Moin Daire562 CE

The annals preserve a notice for a battle at Móin Daire Lothair in their entries for 562. The Annals of Ulster place the notice under AD 562 and state that the Uí Néill of the North won over the Cruithin. The Annals of Tigernach place a parallel notice under Annal T562 and describe the battle as won by the Uí Néill of the north over the Picts, adding that seven Pictish kings fell, including Aodh Brecc. Read together, the texts show a shared battle notice and a difference in detail, without allowing a fuller reconstruction.

Lithographic historical reconstruction: Moin Daire

Year Notice

In the Annals of Ulster, the notice appears under U563.0, with the dating line AD 562. U563.1 records the battle of Móin Daire Lothair as won over the Cruithin by the Uí Néirll of the North. [1]

The Annals of Tigernach preserve a parallel notice under Annal T562 with the annal marker T562.0 and the entry T562.2. Here the battle is Móin Daire Laothair, gained over the Picts by the Uí Néill of the north. The notice also states that seven Pictish kings fell, including Aodh Brecc. This is a different formulation from the Ulster text and belongs to the same annal year as presented in the work, not to a modern year inferred from the identifier. [2]

Battle Record

The two annals agree that the key event for this year is the battle at Móin Daire Lothair or Móin Daire Laothair. Both place the victory with the Uí Néill of the north, though the wording of the defeated group differs: the Annals of Ulster name the Cruithin, while the Annals of Tigernach name the Picts. These are comparable notices, but they are not identical in diction, and the surviving passages do not explain the difference. [1] [2]

The Tigernach notice adds the most specific detail in the excerpts: it says seven Pictish kings fell and identifies Aodh Brecc among them. The Ulster notice in the cited passage does not include that list. Because the texts differ in extent, the safe comparison is limited to what each one actually says. No further sequence of fighting, settlement, or aftermath is stated in the quoted lines for 562 itself. [1] [2]

Named Peoples

The Ulster notice uses the ethnonym Cruithin, while the Tigernach notice uses Picts. In the cited passages these are the principal named groups opposed to the Uí Néill of the north. The texts do not, in the excerpts available here, explain the relation between those designations, and they should not be collapsed into one another without additional evidence. The annal entries themselves preserve the wording as given in each work. [1] [2]

The Tigernach passage also names Aodh Brecc among the fallen. In the same annal cluster, the excerpt records that the battle was gained over the Picts by the Uí Néill of the north. The Ulster passage offers no equivalent list of named dead in the relevant excerpt. The evidence therefore supports a difference in specificity between the two annals, not a claim that one account is fuller in any general sense. [1] [2]

Textual Form

The Irish chronicle texts at CELT are presented in HTML, while the site notes that each text passes through stages of capture, proofing, TEI header creation, structural markup, parsing, and conversion to HTML. The same page says that SGML or TEI is the basis for the texts. This tells us about the published form of the materials used here, not about the year 562 itself. It is relevant only as a description of how the texts are made available. [3]

The annal excerpts themselves show that the work-level headings and the entry numbers are part of the presentation. In the Ulster text, U563.0 precedes the AD 562 line; in Tigernach, Annal T562 and T562.0 mark the corresponding place in the sequence. Those markers should be read as work-specific identifiers, not as modern calendar labels extracted from the number alone. The records remain separate witnesses, each with its own layout and wording. [1] [2]

Sequence Context

The immediately adjacent notices show that the annal sequence around this point includes other entries, but they should not be transferred into 562 unless the text does so. In the Ulster excerpts, the battle notice for Móin Daire Lothair is followed by notices for later years, including deaths and other events under subsequent AD headings. In Tigernach, the battle appears amid a run of entries that include the navigation of Columcill to Ie and other notices in the same annal cluster. [1] [2]

Because the provided passages do not supply a broader narrative for 562, the safest conclusion is limited. The year-level evidence securely contains one battle notice in each annal, but the excerpts do not justify adding causes, strategy, territorial consequences, or political meaning. The records can be compared for wording and specificity, not expanded into a larger historical storyline beyond what the entries directly say. [1] [2]

Comparative Reading

Read side by side, the two notices preserve the same general event and diverge in detail. Ulster states that the battle of Móin Daire Lothair was won over the Cruithin by the Uí Néill of the North. Tigernach states that the battle of Móin Daire Laothair was gained over the Picts by the Uí Néill of the north, and it adds the fall of seven kings, including Aodh Brecc. The comparison is factual and local to the passages themselves. [1] [2]

Nothing in the excerpts requires the historian to choose one wording as a correction of the other. They are separate annal records, each with its own annual framework and phrasing. The evidence supports a narrow conclusion: 562 CE in these annals is marked by a battle notice at Móin Daire Lothair or Laothair, with a more detailed casualty statement preserved in Tigernach and a shorter version in Ulster. [1] [2]

Source References

Hover over a number to see the source. Select it to open the source.

Support Emerald Archives on Buy Me a Coffee
  1. [1] Annals of Ulster
  2. [2] Annals of Tigernach
  3. [3] How texts are made available at CELT

Primary Sources

  1. Annals of Ulster
  2. Annals of Tigernach
  3. How texts are made available at CELT