Comgall Birth516 CE

The surviving Irish annals give only sparse notice for 516 CE. They preserve a birth notice for Comgall of Bennchor, a death notice for Darerca or Moninne of Cill Sleibhe Cuilinn, and in some versions a related note about Conlaed. The manuscripts also disagree in how they align these notices to calendar years, so the year is best treated as a narrowly attested and partly uncertain annalistic horizon rather than a richly documented eventful year.

Lithographic historical reconstruction: Comgall Birth

Annal Entries

The Annals of Ulster place the birth of Comgall of Bennchor under the printed heading for AD 515. Chronicon Scotorum also records Comgall’s birth under AD 515. The Annals of Inisfallen preserve a brief notice for Comgall’s birth but give no explicit AD heading in the excerpt here. [1] [3] [4]

The same narrow cluster of notices includes the death of Darerca of Cill Sleibhe Cuilinn, identified in the Four Masters as Moninne, and in the Annals of Ulster as Dar Ercae of Cill Sléibe Cuilinn. The Annals of Inisfallen also record the repose of bishop Conlaed and the repose of Dar Erca under its 516 entry, while Chronicon Scotorum places Conlaed’s death in 517 rather than 516. That comparison shows that the surviving notices cluster around the same persons and places, but not always under the same year. [1] [2] [3] [4]

The Annals of Ulster also preserve an additional note attached to this year’s entry: it says that, according to another book, the birth of Ciarán belongs to this year. That wording is explicit about uncertainty and shows that even within one annalistic tradition a notice could be attributed to an alternative source rather than stated as firm chronology. [1]

Dating Issues

The chronology is not uniform across the witnesses. In the Annals of Ulster, Comgall’s birth is under the printed heading for 515, while Dar Ercae’s death is under the printed heading for 516. Chronicon Scotorum places Comgall’s birth under AD 515. The Annals of Inisfallen give no explicit AD heading in the excerpt for Comgall’s birth, and the Annals of the Four Masters date Darerca’s death to the Age of Christ 517. [1] [2] [3] [4]

Source References

Hover over a number to see the source. Select it to open the source.

  1. [1] Annals of Ulster
  2. [2] Annals of the Four Masters
  3. [3] Chronicon Scotorum
  4. [4] Annals of Inisfallen

Primary Sources

  1. Annals of Ulster
  2. Annals of the Four Masters
  3. Chronicon Scotorum
  4. Annals of Inisfallen
SHARE OUR HERITAGE

Your research question is too vague

Please ask a clear question. Name the person, place or event you’re interested in, and add a date or period if you know it.

Example “What happened during the Siege of Limerick in 1691?”