Membership is completely free, giving members unlimited access to all available resources, services, features, and benefits without any restrictions or fees.
Welcome back. Sign in to continue enjoying unlimited access to all available resources, services, features, and member benefits at no cost.
Modern calibrated radiocarbon chronologies are expressed as ranges because each result has a statistical uncertainty and because atmospheric carbon levels changed over time. A date such as 31,996 BCE cannot simply be matched to a single radiocarbon measurement. The evidence most relevant to Ireland spans broad intervals: especially roughly 40,000–30,000 radiocarbon years BP in cave-fauna studies, and larger calibrated ranges around them. Nor should “Ireland” be imagined as an unchanging island. Sea levels were lower than today, coastlines lay farther out, and the Irish Sea basin had a different physical geography. Yet water, changing shorelines and ice were formidable constraints on movement.
There are no written sources, inscriptions, graves, houses, hearths or securely excavated tool assemblages from Ireland that can be assigned to 31,997 BCE. Nor can conventional radiocarbon ages be converted into a single historical year without qualification. Radiocarbon results must be calibrated against changing atmospheric carbon levels, and their outcomes are ranges of probability, not anniversary dates. For this early period, a cautious phrase such as around 34,000 years ago is more meaningful than an apparently exact year.
Around this broad date Ireland lay at Europe’s Atlantic north-western edge. Sea level was much lower than today because immense quantities of water were locked in continental ice sheets. The present coastline, Irish Sea and continental shelf cannot simply be projected backwards: exposed plains, changing channels and ice barriers altered routes between Ireland, Britain and continental Europe. Whether a particular crossing was practicable depended not only on distance, but on season, weather, sea ice, rivers and the advance of glaciers. Later reconstructions show Ireland becoming fully engulfed at the Last Glacial Maximum, conventionally placed around 27,000–23,000 calibrated years BP; that maximum lay in the future of the date considered here.
The nearest relevant evidence comes from Castlepook Cave near Doneraile in north County Cork. A reindeer femur from the cave has been described by its researcher, Ruth Carden, and by County Cork heritage publications as bearing a cut mark made when the animal was butchered with a sharp stone tool. The publication places the object at about 31,000 BC. That makes Castlepook unusually pertinent to 31,999 BCE, but it does not licence precision beyond the evidence. A bone’s scientific date is an estimate with an uncertainty range; converting between radiocarbon years, calibrated calendar years and BCE notation introduces further caution. Nor can one cut-marked bone date a particular hunt, season or year.
The island’s familiar outline is misleading for this remote period. Sea level was much lower than today because immense volumes of water were locked in global ice sheets, exposing wider continental shelves around Ireland. Yet lower sea level did not automatically create a walkable land bridge from Ireland to Britain or continental Europe. Research on the Irish Sea has long stressed that any late-glacial connection was, at best, limited, temporary and geographically complex; it should not be assumed for 32,000 BCE. Water, sea ice, rugged coasts and changing glaciers were barriers as well as possible routes.
