Tola Fertola574 CE
The annalistic notices assigned to 574 present a small set of entries rather than a single unified account. One record places the battle of Tola and Fertola in the territories of the Cruithin and adds a death notice for Conall son of Comgall. Another record assigns the same battle to plains between Éile and Osraige, names Fiachra son of Baetán as victor, and gives a fuller topographical gloss. Related annals place a different battle notice under 574 or nearby years, showing that the surviving entries do not align perfectly in year division. This article compares the notices strictly as written.
Dateline
Year Notice
The notices linked to 574 are brief and uneven across the annals. In the Annals of Ulster, the entry headed AD 573 includes the battle of Tola and Fertola, followed by the death of Conall son of Comgall in his sixteenth year of reign. The same compilation then gives AD 574 to the great convention of Druim Ceat, showing that the printed year heading and the notice content do not always match in a simple modern sense. [1]
The Annals of Tigernach place the battle of Tola and Fortola in T572.4. Their T573.1 is the death of Conall son of Comgall, and their T574.1 is the battle of Delgu in Cantyre. [2]
Battle Text
The battle name appears in slightly different forms in different annals. The Annals of Ulster call it the battle of Tola and Fertola and locate it in the territories of the Cruithin. The Annals of Tigernach call it the battle of Tola and Fortola and place it in the plains between Éile and Osraige, between the communities of Clonfert Mullo and Seirkieran. The variation is geographic and lexical, but both notices identify the same paired place-name structure. [1] [2]
The Annals of the Four Masters give the Age of Christ 574, the seventh year of Aedh, and the killing of Aedh, son of Eochaidh Tirmcharna, by the Ui Briuin. [3]
Victors Named
Only some versions identify a victor for the battle. The Annals of Ulster, in the expanded alternative form attached to the Tola and Fertola notice, state that Fiachra son of Baetán was victor. The Annals of Tigernach give the same victory to Fiacha son of Baetán. The spelling differs, but both texts assign victory to a son of Baetán and do not add other combat details. [1] [2]
The same Ulster passage also identifies the places differently, calling them plains between Éile and Osraige and between Cluain Ferta Mo-Lua and Saighir. Tigernach similarly explains the places as plains between Éile and Osraige and between the communities of Clonfert Mullo and Seirkieran. The notices do not say how the battle was fought, only where it was understood to have taken place and who emerged victor. [1] [2]
Linked Deaths
The death of Conall son of Comgall is recorded in the Annals of Ulster, Tigernach, and the Four Masters. In the Annals of Ulster he dies in the sixteenth year of his reign and is described as the ruler who granted the island of Ia to Colum Cille. In Tigernach he is the death entry at T573.1, king of Dálriada in the thirteenth year of his reign, who offered the isle of Ia to Colmcill. In the Four Masters he is the death entry at M572.3, where it is said that he granted Hy Iona to Colum Cille. [1] [2] [3]
The Four Masters preserve that same death in their 572 entry rather than under 574, where they say Conall, son of Comgall, King of Dál Riada, died and that he granted Hy Iona to Colum Cille. Because that notice is not placed under 574 in that compilation, it should be read as a related chronological witness, not as a direct 574-year placement in that text. [3]
Comparative Evidence
Taken together, the annals show a cluster of notices that can be compared without forcing them into one identical chronology. One set places the battle of Tola and Fertola, or Fortola, with an explanation of its geography and a named victor. Another set couples the death of Conall son of Comgall to the same general sequence. The notices are similar in subject matter but not identical in wording or year placement. [1] [2] [3]
In the Annals of Ulster, AD 574 is the heading before the great convention of Druim Ceat at U575.1. Tigernach places the battle of Tola and Fortola at T572.4, Conall's death at T573.1, and the battle of Delgu at T574.1. The Four Masters give M574.2 for the killing of Aedh, son of Eochaidh Tirmcharna, by the Ui Briuin. [1] [2] [3]
Chronological Limits
The surviving passages do not support a fuller reconstruction than the entries allow. They give names, battle titles, place explanations, and selected death notices. They do not explain why the entries differ, and they do not supply a continuous narrative for the year. In this material, the safest conclusion is that 574 is associated with a narrow group of notices, not a single agreed annalistic storyline. [1] [2] [3]
For that reason, the evidence for 574 should be read as a comparison of records rather than a harmonized chronology. The Annals of Ulster, Tigernach, and the Four Masters each preserve relevant notices, but they do so with different headings, different placements, and in one case different year assignment for a related death. The historical value here lies in the explicit record forms, not in any inferred reconciliation. [1] [2] [3]
Source References
Hover over a number to see the source. Select it to open the source.










